Attack Ad Depicts Obama Singing “Zippity Doo Dah”
No, no one has stooped that low. Yet.
But “someone” is heading in that direction. Bill Clinton’s invoking of Jesse Jackson after Obama won the South Carolina primary was a brazen and blatant attempt to drag race into the Democratic nomination process. The release of a photo of Senator Obama wearing African garb, which Clinton campaign manager Maggie Williams failed to deny involvement in, was transparent. Unsubstantiated allegations that photos of Obama have been “darkened” in order to “highlight” his race mirror the infamous Time cover in which the same was done with a photo of OJ Simpson.
Now, video clips of Jeremiah Wright, the former pastor at Obama’s place of worship, Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, have surfaced on YouTube. Reverand Wright married Barack and Michelle Obama, baptized their children, and is a confidante to the Senator and an advisor to the Obama campaign.
Before Wright retired from the Church in February, he gave a lifetime achievement award to Nation of Islam leader Louis Farrakhan, blamed the US government for the AIDS virus, and said the US “deserved” the 9/11 attacks based on a history of racism, colonialism, and oppression.
The Obama campaign has distanced itself somewhat from Wright and his statements. In an interview this morning, the Senator said, “This is a pastor who is on the brink of retirement who in the past has made some controversial statements. I profoundly disagree with some of these statements.“
Demands are increasing for an explanation of the close ties between the Senator and the Reverand; many are also demanding an outright denunciation, putting Obama in the untenable situation of choosing between political expediency and loyalty to a long-time friend.
Setting such demands aside—and it seems clear that the demands are justified by the extreme nature of Wright’s statements—the question remains, exactly who is responsible for the sudden ”surfacing” of these tapes? The fact that every news organization in the country is discussing them now isn’t coincidence.
The two primary suspects, of course, are Obama rivals Hillary Clinton and John McCain. Muddying the waters considerably is the possibility that either Democratic or Republican operatives may have released the tapes with or without the knowledge or permission of the Clinton and McCain campaigns.
A simple calculation might settle the issue. Bringing the tapes into the spotlight at this time favors Senator Clinton; to help Senator McCain, the tapes would have been held for many months. In addition, the Clintons are well known for such tactics, have no compunction about using them, and are increasingly desperate. McCain, on the other hand, isn’t closely associated with dirty politics; in fact, he suffered from similar tactics in 2000, when Bush operatives started a smear campaign claiming that the Arizona Senator had a mixed-race child, and he refused to respond in kind.
Whoever is responsible for these tapes, the news industry is awash in a tacit understanding: don’t allow journalistic standards to interfere with the exploitation of any story. That’s the mentality that gave us Jon Benet and Nathalee, and Paris and Anna; Swaggart and Spitzer, and Haggard and Craig; Power and Ferraro, Bill and Michelle; Reverend Hagee and Reverend Wright.
It’s certainly possible, and I think quite likely, that two things are in play here: first, the Clinton campaign is circulating stories intended to undermine Obama’s candidacy, and second, the media is acting as a willing accomplice, not out of loyalty to Clinton but rather out of the desire to maximize ratings and circulation.
This election should be about policies and the philosophies they reflect, about character and judgment, not about the minutae and innuendo that transfix our easily manipulated media.
Each time a race-baiting photo or tape or rumor or leak surfaces, somebody is operating under cover of darkness to exploit Barack Obama’s skin color, and somebody else is cynically exploiting the subterfuge. I’ll leave it to you to decide who those somebodies are.
Update: Here’s Obama’s response to this controversy at Huffington Post. And now, Rev. Wright is no longer associated with the Obama campaign, though it hasn’t been made clear whether he resigned or was forced out. It should also be noted that while Disney’s “Song of the South” (which featured Uncle Remus singing “Zippity Doo Dah”) has been roundly criticized as racist, many see it as a valuable piece of Southern folklore.
March 14, 2008 at 9:03 pm
I certainly agree that these tactics are dirty, but Obama is in the business of politics. I’m sure the Clinton campaign is responsible for the circulation of these tapes, but I don’t believe that this is too low of a blow. Obama has, after all, made this “minister” one of his close advisors. I’m sure he would continue to have great influence if Obama is elected president. The thought of that crazy guy (who oddly as a preecher says, “D**n America!”) having any influence on the head of the excecutive branch is disgusting. However, if I wanted to smear the Obama campaign, I would do so (easily) with other facts; perhaps ones that actually point the finger at Obama, instead of his minister.
March 14, 2008 at 10:40 pm
People know very little about the black experience and the pain that many of today’s older ministers went through when they were children. That is why they can’t even understand the racial undertones in Hillary’s 3 am ad (why show children sleeping at night with the threat of an intruder and claim that they are afraid of terrorists? To rural white folk in the deep south - Texas - that reminded them of black guys invading at night!). Did you see Peggy Noonan on MSNBC (Morning Joe)? She credited the Democratic party with addressing these issues because they will help America to heal. We have to put it in context, though. Pastor Wright grew up in a day of slavery and saw it in his family. Barack can help us heal as a nation from the pain of the past 400 years. Bill Clinton may have apologized for it but Barack will help us to reconcile as a nation
March 15, 2008 at 8:55 am
While I do not approve of Pastor Wright’s messages that are airing–I do not approve of the divisive tactics of the Clintons. Their attacks on Barack only help assure a win in November for McCain. Barack is to Wright’s messages as Hilliary is to Bill’s adultery.
March 15, 2008 at 4:55 pm
ABC News and Fox “News” bought the racist Wright tapes over a year ago. Hillary had nothing to do with them. Did Hillary Clinton force Trinity United Church to film Wright making racist comments, then force them to sell the tapes to ABC and Fox one year ago?
The picture of Obama in African garb was made available over a year ago by the AP BECAUSE Obama invited the AP to cover his African trip. The right wing website FreeRepublic is responsible for Drudge blaming the Clintons for it.
The “darkened” photos of Obama have been proven to be an embarrassing farce created by DailyKos.
Obama accuses someone close to Hillary, conveniently, after every one of his electoral losess of racism. Whenever Obama feigns outrage about “supposed” racism, it’s always directed at his opponent. He never once denounced the anti-American and anti-White of Rev Wrights, his “mentor” for twenty years, until Wright’s bigotted comments became public knowlege this past week. Meaning, Obama is a fraud who plays the racial issues to his advantage.
March 17, 2008 at 12:30 am
Oxycon Where is it “proven” that DKos had anything to do with Obama’s darkened picture? That staement proves you have a very active imagination, and the rest of your assertions are questionable for that reason. If you told me the sky was blue, I’d have to go look out the window. I would assume that the sky was cloudy. You should seek help.
March 18, 2008 at 3:45 pm
I defiantly agree that politics should be left up to the candidates character, judgments, and what they think about the policies and the philosophies they reflect. You never know what story is true, or what story is false. Sometimes it is just better to not pay attention to the “side” details and pay attention to the more important issues that are going to affect you in the long run.